The same part can often be made in more than one way; the right method depends on quantity, material, geometry and schedule. A wrong choice turns into either an unnecessary tooling investment or extra labour paid on every part. This guide puts the methods we work with at OSKA side by side and lists the questions to ask before deciding.
Five questionsComparisonBy quantityBy materialPrototype to productionPrototype or production tool?FAQ
Five questions before you decide
- How many? Today’s need and the annual total; this sets how many parts share the tooling cost.
- Which material? Plastic, aluminium or steel; the load the part carries and its environment.
- How complex is the geometry? Thin walls, internal voids, undercuts, free-form surfaces.
- What tolerance and surface are expected? Which dimensions are truly critical?
- Schedule and design maturity? If the design is still changing, it may be too early for tooling.
Comparison of methods
| Method | Material | Initial investment | Unit cost | Where it excels | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CNC milling / turning | Metals and engineering plastics | Almost none | High, falls little with quantity | Prototypes, low quantities, tight tolerances, thick solid parts | Stays expensive as quantity grows; tool access in internal voids |
| Plastic injection molding | Thermoplastics | Mold required | Very low | High volumes, thin-walled complex plastic parts, repeatable appearance | A design change means a mold modification |
| Gravity die (permanent mold) casting | Aluminium alloys | Moderate tooling | Medium | Medium volumes, thicker walls, pressure-tight and mechanically sound parts | Very thin walls and very fine detail are limited |
| High-pressure die casting | Aluminium alloys | High; hot-work steel die | Low | High volumes, thin walls, high dimensional repeatability | High tooling cost; porosity can restrict heat treatment and welding |
Choosing by quantity
The logic is simple: tooled methods carry a large initial cost and a very low part cost, while machining has no initial cost but every part carries the same labour. The quantity at which the two curves cross is the break-even point. Below it CNC wins, above it tooling wins. Break-even can be a few hundred for small simple parts and a few thousand for large complex ones; the soundest approach is to price both routes at the quotation stage.
Choosing by material
| Part material | Low quantity | Medium quantity | High quantity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plastic | CNC machining from block | Injection molding in a prototype (rapid) tool | Injection molding in a production tool |
| Aluminium | CNC machining from block | Gravity die casting + machining of key surfaces | Die casting + machining of key surfaces |
| Steel and stainless | CNC turning / milling | CNC turning / milling in series with fixtures | Cast or forged blank + machining, depending on the part |
Most castings are not finished on their own: gasket faces, bearing bores and threads are machined to size afterwards. Planning the tool and the machining in one workshop means machining allowances and datums are right from the start.
Three stages from prototype to production
Prototype tool or production tool?
| Prototype (rapid) tool | Production tool | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Verify the design in the real material, produce a pilot run | Long-term, uninterrupted series production |
| Tool material | Aluminium or pre-hardened steel | Hardened mold steel |
| Construction | Single cavity, simple; undercuts mostly by hand-loaded inserts | Can be multi-cavity; slides, lifters and automatic ejection |
| Cooling and cycle | Simple cooling, longer cycle | Cooling designed for the shortest cycle |
| Life | Limited number of shots | Very high shot counts with maintenance |
| Time and cost | Shorter and lower | Longer and higher; lowest cost per part |
Frequently Asked Questions
At what quantity does tooling make sense?
There is no single number. The longer the CNC cycle and the simpler the tool, the lower the break-even quantity. Send us your drawing and we can price both routes and look at the break-even point together.
My design is not final yet. Should I start the tool?
We would not recommend it. Every change in steel costs time and money. The safest route is to progress with CNC prototypes until the design matures, verify it with mold flow analysis, and then cut the tool.
Does a machined prototype behave like a molded part?
Not exactly, even in the same material. In a molded part, flow direction, weld lines and internal stresses affect mechanical behaviour. A prototype is reliable for checking dimensions and assembly; for parts near their strength limit a pilot molding run is advisable.
Can a part move from gravity die casting to die casting later?
It can, but the design rules differ: wall thickness, draft and gating all change. If a transition is likely, tell us at the start so the part is designed to suit both.